Halloween in St. Augustine 2026: The Candy Is on the 24th, the 31st Is for Grown-Ups

Your complete St. Augustine Halloween guide for 2026 — every confirmed date, the ghost stories that hold up, and an honest verdict on the tour we took.

When we moved down here, I came first. Nicole and the kids were still up north for another week, and I’d rented us a house — sight mostly unseen — across from the Old Jail on San Marco.

The first night, I heard it. Shouting. A crowd. What sounded unmistakably like a fight breaking out in the dark, and then a heavy, awful thud. Then it happened again the next night. And the next.

I lay there doing the math on what I’d just signed us up for, and I thought: well. Nicole is going to kill me. I have moved my family into a bad neighborhood.

It was the ghost tour. Every night, the trolley pulls up to the Old Jail, and every night they stage the hangings — the shouting, the drop, the whole production — for a crowd of tourists standing in the yard fifty feet from where I was trying to sleep. It took me four nights to work that out.

We stayed. And for the next couple of years, whenever anyone visited and asked, in that careful voice people use, “…what is that noise?” — we’d just say: oh, that’s the hangings. And go back to dinner.

That’s how we got to know St. Augustine Halloween season. So here’s everything we’ve learned since: every confirmed 2026 date, which ghost tours actually earn the money, and the ghost stories that survive a look at the record — including the hangings, which turn out to be a better story than the tour tells.

But first, the one scheduling fact that trips up every family that visits.

The Candy Is on Saturday the 24th. Halloween Night Is a Different Party.

Halloween 2026 falls on Saturday, October 31 — which sounds like a gift, and is, but not the way visitors expect.

The organized trick-or-treating is a week early, on Saturday, October 24. St. George Street, the Ximenez-Fatio House, Ancient City Kids Day, the Alligator Farm — all of it stacks on that one Saturday. If you bring kids downtown on the 31st expecting candy, there isn’t any.

And Halloween night itself has quietly become the adult night. Two real events now anchor it downtown, plus the lighthouse running its fullest slate of the month. That’s new, and it’s worth planning around.

Saturday, October 24 — the full stack

Time	Event	Where
8:00 a.m.	Jail Break 5K (10th annual)	Starts at the Old Jail, 167 San Marco Ave
11:00 a.m.–3:00 p.m.	Ancient City Kids Day — free	Francis Field, 25 W Castillo Dr
1:00–4:00 p.m.	St. George Street Trick-or-Treating — free	North St. George Street
1:00–4:00 p.m.	Ximenez-Fatio Trick-or-Treat & Harvest Festival — free	20 Aviles St
5:30–9:00 p.m.	Creatures of the Night	St. Augustine Alligator Farm
5:00–9:00 p.m.	Hastings Trunk or Treat & Movie in the Park — free	6140 Main St, Hastings
6:30 & 7:30 p.m.	Mortality & Mourning: Women in Black	Ximenez-Fatio House
8:00 p.m.–midnight	Headless Bangers Costume Ball, 18+	Renaissance at World Golf Village
8:00–10:00 p.m.	Improv Spooktacular	Third Space Improv, 200 Malaga St

Saturday, October 31 — Halloween night

Time	Event	Where
10:00 a.m.–10:00 p.m.	Sykes Farms “Tractor Treat” — costume parade, contest, trick-or-treating	Elkton
4:00–10:00 p.m.	The Alchemist’s Assembly — immersive Halloween festival, vendors, live music. Ticketed.	Francis Field
6:30 & 7:30 p.m.	Mortality & Mourning, final night	Ximenez-Fatio House
7:00–9:30 p.m.	ESTUSCARY Haunted Trail, final night	GTM Reserve, Ponte Vedra
7:30 / 8:00 / 8:30 / 9:00 p.m.	Dark of the Moon — four departures, fullest night of the month	St. Augustine Lighthouse
8:00–10:00 p.m.	Improv Spooktacular, final night	Third Space Improv
9:00 p.m.–1:00 a.m.	Prohibition Kitchen’s Vaudeville Halloween Extravaganza, 21+	119 St. George St
Midnight–2:30 a.m.	Old Jail After Dark	167 San Marco Ave

So: bring the kids on the 24th. Come back without them on the 31st. That’s the whole strategy, and almost nobody tells you.

St. Augustine Halloween with Kids: Where the Trick-or-Treating Actually Is

Creatures of the Night at the Alligator Farm — start here

This is the one we’d send any family to first.

Friday, October 23 and Saturday, October 24, 2026. Gates 5:00 p.m., event 5:30–9:00 p.m. You walk the park after dark — a completely different park than the one you visited in daylight — collecting treats from stations along the way while the keepers bring out the nocturnal animals. It is deliberately not a scare event. No jump scares, nobody chasing anyone. Costumes, treats, and creatures doing what creatures do after sunset.

• Bring your own treat bag. The park says it outright and people forget every year.
• Tickets are online only. There are no walk-ups.
• Pricing: non-members $20 adults, $16 children 2–11; members $18 and $14; under 2 free.
• Ages 2 and up, genuinely family-friendly.
• 999 Anastasia Blvd — five minutes over the bridge, free on-site parking, which downtown very much is not.

One correction worth making, because we nearly repeated it: some listings say this runs three nights, October 23–25, ending at 8:00. It doesn’t. It’s two nights, ending at 9:00 — straight off the Alligator Farm’s own page, which is current.

If you’ve never done the Alligator Farm in daylight, it’s worth its own trip — our up-close visit is here, including the rookery, which most visitors walk straight past.

St. George Street Trick-or-Treating

Saturday, October 24, 2026, 1:00–4:00 p.m. Free, all ages. The 21st annual, run by Ancient City Tours.

Three hundred–plus shops and restaurants along the pedestrian stretch hand out candy, and — this is the detail that makes it work — participating storefronts mark themselves with orange and black balloons. It turns the whole street into a scavenger hunt instead of a guessing game.

Note the time: it’s daytime, 1 to 4. Not evening. Every year somebody shows up at six.

Ximenez-Fatio House Harvest Festival

Saturday, October 24, 1:00–4:00 p.m., 20 Aviles Street, free (donations accepted). Trick-or-treating on the museum grounds plus games and prizes, with museum tours at regular admission if you want them.

It runs in exactly the same window as St. George Street, and they’re a six-minute walk apart. Realistically you do one properly, or half of each and accept the hustle. Our call: St. George Street for the volume and the balloon hunt, Ximenez-Fatio if you’ve got little ones who’d rather not be in a crowd.

The corn maze and the pumpkin patches

Sykes Family Farms Crop Maze, Elkton, is the county’s big one. Saturday, October 3 through Sunday, November 1, 2026, weekends only: Fridays 6–10 p.m., Saturdays 10 a.m.–10 p.m., Sundays 10 a.m.–5 p.m., last entry an hour before close. $16.99 general, ages 3+, free under 2 — and $14.99 for military or seniors 65+ with ID, which is the kind of discount that never gets advertised.

Two things on their calendar you won’t find in the roundups: Glow Nights on select October Fridays (we couldn’t confirm 2026 dates on any source the farm controls — call (904) 692-1370), and a “Tractor Treat” on Halloween itself, October 31, 6–10 p.m. — costume parade, contest, and trick-or-treating, running inside normal farm hours. If you want your kids in costume collecting candy on Halloween, that’s the organized option in this county.

For pumpkins without the drive: First United Methodist at 118 King Street — locally “the Pumpkin Church” — opens October 8, 11 a.m. to 7 p.m. daily while the supply lasts. Walkable from anywhere downtown, which makes it the easy one for visitors. Fair warning: their deliveries have run late in past years, so don’t drive in on opening morning expecting a full lot. Shores United Methodist, 724 Shores Blvd, runs October 12–31, free admission, with a trunk-or-treat on the 30th.

Trunk-or-treats across the county

All free, all ages:

• Fri Oct 16, 5:30 p.m. — Tricks and Treats, hosted by the St. Augustine Beach Police Department at their station, 2300 A1A S. (The city’s own calendar lists the end time as both 7:30 and 8:00 — plan for 7:30 and you can’t be wrong.)
• Sun Oct 18, 5:00–7:00 p.m. — Good News Church Hello Fall Trunk or Treat & Chili Cook-Off, 1357 Wildwood Dr
• Sat Oct 24, 5:00 p.m. — 365 Church Harvest Fest, 3605 Lewis Speedway
• Wed Oct 28, 5:30–7:30 p.m. — First Baptist at Nocatee, 1770 Valley Ridge Blvd
• Thu Oct 29, 4:00–7:00 p.m. — St. Johns Monster Bash, Fountains at St. Johns
• Fri Oct 30, 6:00–7:00 p.m. — St. Augustine Shores UMC, 724 Shores Blvd
• Sat Oct 31, 9:00 a.m.–noon — Pharoahs Car Club Cruise In & Trunk or Treat, Trout Creek Memorial Park

If you’re building a whole weekend around kids, most of what we’d recommend year-round is in St. Augustine With Kids: Budget-Friendly Things to Do.

The Ghost Tours: Our Honest Verdict

A ghost tour is the default St. Augustine Halloween activity, which is exactly why it’s worth being picky about. We did the lantern-lit walking tour — Ghost Tours of St. Augustine, out of 4 Granada Street, across from Flagler College. It’s the original; they’ve run since 1994 and bill themselves as Florida’s first ghost tour. $25, 75 minutes, Thursday through Saturday at 8:00 p.m., capped at 25 people, free for kids 6 and under.

We had a great time. Genuinely — walking our own streets at night behind a guide with a lantern, hearing the version the archives support next to the version the tours tell, and being able to tell which was which. Nicole recognized a corner we’d driven past a hundred times and never once stood on in the dark.

And here’s the caveat, which is the whole point of this section: it depends enormously on your guide.

That isn’t us being uncharitable. It’s structural, and the operator says so. Their own listing states that “tours are not scripted, so each guide may end the tour a different place.” They market on it — “no scripts, no gimmicks” — and it is why a good guide is so good. But when the route itself changes by guide, you’re not buying a product. You’re buying a performer. Some nights that’s a gift. Some nights it isn’t. This tour runs 3.5 out of 5 across 156 TripAdvisor ratings, the lowest of the major operators in town, and the bad reviews cluster on exactly one thing: a guide who read it flat. One described a guide so monotone that people peeled off mid-tour.

We got a good one. We’d go again. We’d also tell you plainly that we can’t promise you the night we got.

You can’t escape the guide lottery — you can only choose your failure mode

The pattern, when we went looking, is weirdly symmetrical.

The unscripted walking tours — this one, A Ghostly Encounter, Ghost City Tours — get the flat performer complaint. Dry. “Basically a history lesson.” One Ghost City reviewer called it “high school history taught by a substitute.”

The scripted, theatrical trolley — Ghosts & Gravestones, costumed actors and jump scares — gets the exact opposite complaint. “So theatrical and scripted it did not feel natural, and it made the accuracy of the stories questionable.” “Over the top, sounded memorized, and was at times almost embarrassing.”

So booking the polished one doesn’t solve it. It changes which way it goes wrong.

And no operator here lets you request a guide. We checked all of them; there’s no published mechanism anywhere. What actually works is narrower: call instead of booking online, name a guide from a recent review, ask which nights they work. Or sidestep it entirely.

What we’d actually book

The less a tour depends on a person talking, the less the lottery matters.

1. Old Jail After Dark — if you do one paid thing, this. Two and a half hours inside the 1891 jail after midnight, twelve people, with a FLIR thermal camera, spirit box, dowsing rods and a laser grid. $106.49, or $96.10 booking online. Ages 13+, nightly, midnight to 2:30 a.m., 167 San Marco Ave. Nothing else in this city gives you that much access to a building you otherwise see for thirty minutes in daylight. Twelve seats a night and non-refundable — book this first.

(And yes. That’s the building I spent four nights convinced was a crime scene.)

2. Dark of the Moon at the Lighthouse. $29.95 adults and seniors, $24.95 children 12 and under. Ninety minutes, and you climb the tower at night by glowstick. Hard gate: age 7 minimum and 44 inches minimum, and the child has to climb under their own power — no carrying.

October 2026 runs the 2nd, 3rd, 4th, 9th, 10th, 11th, 14th, 16th, 17th, 18th, 23rd, 24th, 25th, 28th, 30th and 31st — Fridays through Sundays, plus bonus Wednesdays on the 14th and 28th. Start times vary by night between 7:30 and 9:00, so check the calendar rather than assuming. Halloween night has the fullest slate of the month: four departures at 7:30, 8:00, 8:30 and 9:00.

Fair warning: regulars say the guiding has thinned and the guides largely let you roam. For a local who already knows the Pittee story, that’s a feature — you came for the building. 100 Red Cox Rd; you drive, it isn’t walkable from downtown.

3. GhoSt Augustine’s Dead Walk, $24 — if you’ve already done the standard circuit. Every other operator works the same north-of-the-plaza corridor: City Gate, Huguenot, the fort. GhoSt Augustine goes south, genuinely different ground. They’re also the best-rated operator in town, 4.6 across 3,212 reviews — the strongest rating-times-volume figure here.

4. The $8.99 option. VoiceMap’s self-guided “Night Watchman’s St. Augustine” — 24 stops over 1.1 miles, GPS-triggered, downloads offline. A third the price of any guided tour, and it eliminates the guide lottery completely. For a local who wants route ideas rather than a performance, it’s the best value in the category and it isn’t close.

Also from the lantern-tour operator, if that’s your pick: the Creepy Crawl Haunted Pub Tour (Thu–Sat, 7:00 p.m., $25 including your first drink, 21+, capped at 18) and a Paranormal Investigation of the old fort grounds (Thu–Sat, 8:30 p.m., $35 with equipment — note this is the Castillo exterior and the Santo Domingo Redoubt, not inside the fort). Reservations (904) 829-1122. Their private VIP tour is $350 flat for up to 25 people, discounted $100 for September and October 2026 — so $250. At twenty-plus people that’s cheaper per head than public tickets, and when you call to book you can ask for a guide by name. Which is the only reliable way to beat the lottery.

Quick comparison

Tour	Format	Price	Ages	Inside buildings?
A Ghostly Experience (lantern walk)	Walking, 75 min, max 25, Thu–Sat 8 p.m.	$25	Free under 6	No
Ghosts & Gravestones	Trolley, 80 min, nightly from 8 p.m.	from $30.60 direct	PG-13	Yes — Old Jail, Potter’s, Cromwell’s Parlour
GhoSt Augustine Dead Walk	Walking + K2, 90 min	$24 / $15 kids	6+	No
A Ghostly Encounter	Walking, 90 min	from $30	All ages	No
Dark of the Moon	Lighthouse, 90 min	$29.95 / $24.95 under 12	7+, 44″ min	Yes — tower + keeper’s house
Old Jail After Dark	Investigation, 2.5 hr, max 12	$96.10 online	13+	Yes
Ghost City Tours	Walking, 90 min	$29.99 / $14.99	All ages, no jump scares	No
Creepy Crawl Pub Tour	Pub crawl, max 18	$25 incl. first drink	21+	Yes — 4+ taverns
VoiceMap self-guided	Audio, 60 min	$8.99	Any	No

The St. Augustine Halloween Ghost Stories That Are Actually True

This is the part we enjoyed researching most, and it changed how we hear the tours. Half of what gets told on a St. Augustine Halloween tour is real. The other half is not, and the difference is findable.

St. Augustine does not need invented ghosts. The documented history on these twelve blocks is darker than anything a guide would make up — and a startling amount of what gets repeated nightly is provably wrong.

The Old Jail — where my hangings came from

Start with the building I couldn’t sleep across from.

Henry Flagler donated $10,000 to build this jail in 1891 for one reason: the old county jail sat next to his Hotel Ponce de León and he wanted the prisoners moved away from his guests. A man relocated the county jail because inmates were bad for tourism. That’s the real story, and it’s perfect.

It was built by the Pauly Jail Building Company of St. Louis — the same firm that later built Alcatraz. Seventy-two inmates, plus living quarters for the sheriff and his family in the south wing. The state historical marker is blunter than any tour guide: “The conditions were primitive for most of its history with up to four inmates in a cell, no indoor plumbing until 1914 and open barred windows.”

Now, about those hangings.

You’ll hear that eight men were hanged on the jail grounds. It’s on the attraction’s own pages, on the historical marker entry, on the tourism bureau’s site. It’s also, as far as we can tell, the thing being dramatized in the yard every night at eight o’clock.

We went looking for the eight. Florida’s documented list of pre-1972 executions records five in St. Johns County — in 1769, 1828, 1837, 1848 and 1886. Every single one of them predates this jail, which opened in 1891. And Florida abolished local hangings effective January 1, 1924, moving executions to the state prison at Raiford. So the entire window in which a legal hanging could have happened here is 1891 to 1923 — and the state’s list shows none.

That list may be incomplete, so we won’t call the figure false. We’ll call it uncorroborated — and note that after 1924, no hanging could legally have happened there at all.

Which means the noise that convinced me I’d moved my family into a war zone was a nightly reenactment of an execution count nobody can verify. I’ve made my peace with it.

Sheriff Charles Joseph Perry gets the same treatment. Tours call him a harsh warden, one of the toughest in the South. The St. Johns County Sheriff’s Office remembers him differently: six foot six, three hundred pounds, sheriff across split terms from 1889 to 1919, and “apparently very popular and reputed to have gone on the most dangerous calls right along with his deputies.”

And the genuinely dark fact the tours skip entirely: Deputy Guy White was killed on March 5, 1911, while disarming four prisoners. A deputy actually died here. That’s worth more than a gallows count nobody can stand behind.

The Lighthouse, and the story that holds up completely

July 10, 1873. The new tower was under construction, and a railway handcart ran supplies from the dock up to the site. The keeper’s children rode it downhill for fun. A wooden board at the end of the rail was the only thing stopping the cart from running into the water — and that day the board wasn’t in place.

Mary Adelaide Pittee, 15, and Eliza Pittee, 13, drowned. So did an unnamed African-American girl of 10, believed to be the daughter of a worker at the site. Carrie Pittee, 4, survived — pulled out by Dan Sessions, a young Black worker who reached the cart and lifted it off the girls.

Two things the tours get wrong. Mary and Eliza aren’t buried here — the Pittee family took them home to Maine. And the fourth girl’s name is genuinely unknown; the museum is still working its archives to identify her. Psychics on tours have offered “Ellie” and “Eleanor.” There’s no record behind either, and inventing a name for a child nobody bothered to record feels like the wrong direction to take that story.

The other death at the lighthouse is better than the ghost story anyway. Keeper Joseph Andreu fell roughly sixty feet from scaffolding while whitewashing the tower and died just before Christmas, 1859. His widow, Maria Mestre de los Dolores Andreu, was appointed keeper on January 7, 1860 — the first Hispanic-American woman to command a federal shore installation, at the same pay as the men. The Confederacy darkened the light in 1861. She received no pay and no protection, moved to Georgia, and died in obscurity.

We’ll take that over a girl in a blue dress. And there’s no record of what any of them were wearing.

Worth saying: the museum’s own position is unusually honest. They publish the anecdotes and state plainly that “we cannot explain the events that are reported to us on our tours.” They don’t assert. That’s rarer in this business than it should be.

The Castillo — where the Park Service debunks its own ghost story

The famous one: Colonel García Martí catches his wife Dolores with his aide Captain Abela, seals them alive in a dungeon chamber, and in 1833 a lieutenant breaks through a wall and finds two skeletons in chains. The perfume still drifts through the corridors.

The National Park Service says no. In their own audio piece on the dungeon they state it was the old gunpowder magazine, later used for storage and then trash; the Spanish closed it with nobody inside; and the bones found when it was reopened were “probably just trash.” They also identify what the legend seems to garble — the true story of María Dominga de Zéspedes, the governor’s daughter, who secretly married an Irish officer against her father’s wishes in 1784. It ends happily. Church wedding, son born in 1788.

What the Park Service does document is far heavier.

November 29, 1837. Twenty-one of twenty-two Seminole prisoners escaped through a cell window five feet wide and eight inches tall, fifteen feet above the floor. Only Osceola stayed — too ill to go, having been captured weeks earlier after approaching a parley under a white flag of truce. He died in custody at Fort Moultrie. And per the Seminole Tribe’s own historic preservation office: to this day nobody knows how Coacoochee engineered that escape. The Army’s version was disputed by Coacoochee himself. Most modern Seminoles trace their heritage to those twenty men who got out.

Then 1886–87: roughly 502 Apache prisoners held in a fort built for about 150. The fort physician documented 24 deaths — one man, seven women, and sixteen children — of dysentery, bronchitis and tuberculosis. Twelve children were born there. All of the dead were buried on North Beach, in what’s now Vilano, in unmarked graves nobody has located. A hundred and three children were shipped to the Carlisle Indian School; more than a quarter of them died there.

Sixteen dead Apache children in unmarked graves a few miles from where you’re standing. You don’t need a walled-up mistress.

Huguenot Cemetery, and the monument over an empty grave

Established 1821 in the middle of a yellow fever epidemic, because Tolomato was Catholic-only and non-Catholics had nowhere to go. Half an acre. At least 436 burials.

Judge John B. Stickney died in 1882 and lies under a nine-foot marble monument — except he doesn’t. Years later his grown children had him exhumed to rebury him in Washington, D.C. The gravediggers left the casket unattended, thieves reportedly stole his gold teeth, and the workers closed it up and said nothing. His remains went to Washington. The monument is still here and the judge is not.

The teeth are strong local tradition; we couldn’t find a contemporaneous account. The empty grave under the grand monument is the documented part, and it’s plenty.

What you should not believe: any specific death toll for the 1821 epidemic. The Florida Division of Historical Resources says it outright — four known marked burials connected to the outbreak, local accounts of mass burials, and “the exact number of people who perished from the epidemic is unknown.” If a guide gives you a number, they made it up.

Ripley’s, and the fire everyone gets half right

April 23, 1944. Fire on the third and fourth floors of the Castle Warden Hotel. Two women died: Bette Neville Richeson, from a prominent Jacksonville family, in Room 17, and Ruth Pickering in the penthouse.

The part the tours bury: the hotel was owned by Norton Baskin and his wife, Marjorie Kinnan Rawlings — the Pulitzer winner who wrote The Yearling. Ruth Pickering was their friend. She died in their hotel.

What’s unresolved, as Ripley’s themselves tell it: the official cause was a lit cigarette but no proof was ever found; both women were found with wet towels around their faces and no burn marks; and a guest registered only as “Mr. X” checked in the night before, was seen carrying something like a rolled-up rug, ordered extra towels, and vanished after the fire — the towels never found in his room. We’d flag that we found no fire-marshal report backing the towel details. That’s the story the property tells, not forensics. The two deaths and the date are solid.

Tolomato Cemetery — and the best quote in this post

Two hundred years of burials at 14 Cordova Street. The oldest marker belongs to Elizabeth Forrester, died December 20, 1798 — often called Florida’s oldest marked grave, and per the University of South Florida’s documentation, her tomb was robbed shortly after she was buried.

Also here: General Jorge Biassou, a Haitian Revolution leader sometimes called America’s first Black general, in an unmarked grave. Father Félix Varela, a candidate for sainthood, who lay here about sixty years before his remains went home to Havana in 1911 — his chapel still stands. The cemetery closed in 1884, when the city shut every burial ground inside the limits over yellow fever. Two families buried relatives anyway and were fined $25 each.

The boy’s statue you’ll hear about is identified on tours as “Little James” — James P. Morgan, who died November 28, 1877, at five years and ten days. We should be straight: we could not find any source that actually ties the statue to him, or to Elizabeth Forrester, and several ghost-tour sites conflate the two. The docents who maintain the place would know. That’s a good reason to go.

And go you can — free. Tolomato opens the third Saturday of each month, 11 a.m. to 2 p.m., docents on site. October’s open day is Saturday the 17th, starting at 10:30 rather than 11 — it’s paired with a DAR Patriot Remembrance Day.

Here’s the kicker: Huguenot Cemetery opens the same third Saturday, 11 to 2, also free, three blocks away. Two of the most storied burial grounds in Florida, open together, one morning a month, no charge, with knowledgeable people standing in them — and almost nobody knows. Best free morning in haunted St. Augustine, and it isn’t close.

Last word to Elizabeth Gessner of the Tolomato Cemetery Preservation Association, who told NPR — of the cemetery the ghost tours built an industry around:

“We have nothing but happy dead here.”

A word on what’s circulating out there

We’ll say this plainly, because it slowed our research and it will slow yours: several high-ranking “haunted St. Augustine” websites are publishing fabricated history. Invented ghosts with invented names and dates that contradict the properties’ own records — a physician who supposedly died in 1672 at a building constructed in 1914, a judge’s death moved fifty years and given a cause that never happened, an 1798 ledger stone turned into a walking apparition in period dress.

If a story arrives with a suspiciously complete name, date and backstory and no source, be skeptical. The real history is sitting in the Park Service’s files and the Sheriff’s Office’s own history page, and it’s worse than the fiction.

Where to Find Haunted Houses in the Area

If what you want is a proper haunted house — a building, a queue, actors coming out of the dark at you — St. Johns County does not have one. Not one. We went looking properly and the nearest real one is forty minutes up I-95.

That surprised us, in a city that sells ghosts for a living. But the St. Augustine Halloween business is built on history: tours, cemeteries, candlelit museums. Nobody here runs a scream park. So if your teenager wants to be genuinely frightened, you’re driving to Arlington.

13th Floor Jacksonville — the only real one

9230 Arlington Expressway, Jacksonville. Select nights September 12 through November 7, 2026, with entry slots every fifteen minutes from 6:00 p.m. Three attractions this year: Coopersville High, Sirens Wake and Black Hollow Asylum. Rated too intense for children 12 and under. Free street parking, no lot.

Here’s the thing worth knowing, and it’s a real money-saver: the price swings by night, and it isn’t advertised anywhere obvious. Halloween is $32.99. But Sunday October 4, Monday October 12 and closing night November 7 are $19.99 — the same three haunts for thirteen dollars less.

Night	General admission
Sun Oct 4 · Mon Oct 12 · Sat Nov 7	$19.99 — the cheap nights
Most Sundays, Wednesdays, Thursdays	$27.99
Fri Oct 9, Fri Oct 16, Sun Oct 25, Tue Oct 27–Thu Oct 29	$29.99
Sat Oct 10, Sat Oct 17, Fri Oct 23, Sat Oct 24, Fri Oct 30, Sat Oct 31	$32.99 — peak
Closed entirely	Oct 1, 5, 6, 7, 8, 13, 19, 20, 26

Upgrades run Fast Pass $47.99, Skip The Line $62.99, and Platinum $94.99. We’d skip Platinum — it’s nearly triple general admission for perks most people won’t use. Fast Pass on a Saturday is the one that actually earns its money, because the queue on October 24 is the queue.

The free one, and it’s better than it has any right to be

Hall of Terror at Palm Coast Fire Station 21, 9 Corporate Drive, Palm Coast. Friday October 30 and Saturday October 31, 7–10 p.m. Free. This year’s theme is Universal Monsters, and the city itself compares it to Halloween Horror Nights — which is a bold claim for a firefighter-built walkthrough, but the thing has a real reputation.

The detail that made us include it: there’s a low-sensory hour from 6:00 to 7:00 p.m. before the scares start. Lights up, noise down. If you have a kid who wants to be brave but can’t do strobes and screaming, that hour is a genuinely thoughtful piece of programming and almost nobody offers it. Forty-five minutes south of us and it costs nothing.

The rest of the field

• ESTUSCARY Haunted Trail, GTM Research Reserve, Ponte Vedra Beach — Oct 29, 30, 31, 7:00–9:30 p.m., $20 online / $30 at the trail, ages 10+. Hayrides, candy, costumes encouraged, closed-toe shoes. Note the price jumped: 2025 was $15 online and $20 at the gate. This is the family-scary option and it runs on Halloween itself.
• Jacksonville Zoo Spooktacular — Oct 10, 15–18, 22–25, 29–31, 6–10 p.m., timed entry. $25 member / $35 non-member in advance, $30 / $40 day-of. A 400-foot light tunnel, trick-or-treat stations, a Skeleton Disco, and an optional scare zone you can walk around. The big not-scary family alternative.
• The Haunted Trail at Conner’s A-Maize-Ing Acres, Hilliard — October 31 only, dusk to 10 p.m. Down from two nights in 2025, when it ran as Field of Screams. Ticket price isn’t posted yet.

The Farms: Where to Actually Pick a Pumpkin

The question we get every October: where do you actually pick a pumpkin off a vine around here? Short answer, Wesley Wells — and it’s open more of October than the festival date suggests.

Wesley Wells Farms — the only true u-pick in St. Augustine

2680 Ada Arnold Rd. Their Pumpkin Festival & Handmade Market is Saturday, September 26, 9 a.m.–4 p.m. — before October even starts, which catches people out every year.

But the festival isn’t the good part. They stay open for u-pick every Saturday after it — October 3, 10, 17, 24 and 31 — with pumpkins, vegetables and flowers. One crowded Saturday in September, then four quiet ones in October. Take the quiet ones. Pumpkins are priced by the pound after you pick, separate from admission, and there’s no ATM on site. Wear boots; a wagon helps.

Festival tickets weren’t on sale as of this writing, six days out — their page still says “coming soon.” Last year was $15 online, $18 at the gate. Call (904) 679-5660 rather than turning up and hoping.

Sykes Family Farms — the corn maze

5995 Brough Rd, Elkton. October 3 – November 1, weekends only: Fridays 6–10 p.m., Saturdays 10 a.m.–10 p.m., Sundays 10 a.m.–5 p.m., last entry an hour before close. $16.99 ages 3+, $14.99 seniors 65+ and military with ID, free under 2, $15 a head for groups of 20+.

Nine acres, themed maze passports, hay rides, axe throwing, bounce pads, duck races. Two things nobody tells you: you need one flashlight or glow stick per group to enter the maze after dark, and the Farmers Kitchen is cash only (there is an ATM). Tractor Treat is Saturday October 31, 6–10 p.m. — treats plus a costume contest.

You’ll see Glow Nights mentioned for select October Fridays. We couldn’t confirm 2026 dates on any source the farm controls, so call (904) 692-1370 before planning around one. And don’t be thrown by their homepage banner reading “2025 Crop Maze” above 2026 dates — it’s a stale label, the dates are right.

Worth the drive

• Congaree and Penn, Jacksonville — Fall on the Farm, Fri/Sat/Sun from September 25 to November 1, 5 p.m. to dusk in early season, 4 p.m. after October 9. $10 for ages 12+, $5 for ages 2–11, $8 seniors and military — and only $5 a head if you have a dining reservation. Pumpkin patch, live music, food truck, farm bar. Tickets on arrival only. This is the cheapest good evening on this entire list. If it rains more than a drizzle the music, truck and bar are cancelled.
• Amazing Grace Family Farms, Green Cove Springs — the region’s other corn maze. October 2–31, Fridays 4–9, Saturdays 10–9. $17.95 online, $24.95 at the gate — a seven-dollar penalty for not buying ahead, so buy ahead. The ticket isn’t date-specific; use it any operating day.

Pumpkin patches — the full list

Patch	Where	2026 season
First United Methodist — “the Pumpkin Church”	118 King Street, downtown	Opens Oct 7, while supplies last
St. Augustine Shores UMC	724 Shores Blvd	Oct 12–31
Happy Haunts	895 Palm Valley Rd, Ponte Vedra	Oct 3–31 — Mon–Fri 3–7, Sat–Sun 11–9
River of Life UMC	2600 Race Track Rd, St. Johns	Sept 28 – Oct 31
Wesley Wells Farms (u-pick)	2680 Ada Arnold Rd	Sept 26 festival, then Saturdays
Isle of Faith UMC (Jacksonville)	1821 San Pablo Rd S	Oct 3–31, free admission, donation pricing

If you’re in Nocatee or the northern end of the county, Happy Haunts and River of Life are much closer than the King Street patch and nobody seems to know it. And the Jacksonville one is worth the mention because it’s free, volunteer-run and pets are welcome — with a craft fair October 3, Military Appreciation October 10, Bring Your Pet Day October 17, a trunk-or-treat October 24 and buy-one-get-one on Halloween.

St. Augustine Halloween for Grown-Ups

The grown-up half of St. Augustine Halloween has quietly gotten better. Halloween night, Saturday October 31:

• The Alchemist’s Assembly — 4:00–10:00 p.m., Francis Field, 25 W Castillo Dr. An immersive Halloween festival: artisan vendors, “mystical experiences,” live music, food and drink. Costumes encouraged. Ticketed. (Not a City event, though it’s on the city calendar.) This is the downtown Halloween-night anchor that didn’t exist a few years ago.
• Prohibition Kitchen’s 10th Annual Vaudeville Halloween Extravaganza — 9:00 p.m.–1:00 a.m., 119 St. George Street, 21+, admission from $75. Live music from Dr. Sick and the Etcetera Orchestra — members of the Squirrel Nut Zippers — plus circus performers. Tenth year running, and the only bar in town that’s posted anything for 2026.

Earlier in the month:

• Sat Oct 3, 6:00–9:00 p.m. — CROCtoberfest (Brew at the Zoo), Alligator Farm. Strictly 21 and over; no children, including infants.
• Sat Oct 10, 8:00 p.m. — Drag Queen-a-Palooza: Halloween Edition, Third Space Improv, 200 Malaga St. $25 advance / $30 door, 18+, hosted by Karrissa T. Wade.
• Select Fri & Sat, Oct 2–31 — Beetlejuice Pub Crawl, The Tasting Tours, 5 Palm Row Ste D. four stops, 2.5 hours, 21+. Two sources give two prices — $40 and $95 — so confirm when you call (904) 325-3911. Runs on both the 30th and the 31st. (Start time is listed as both 6:00 and 5:30 depending on the page — confirm at booking.)
• Sat Oct 24, 8:00 p.m.–midnight — 10th Annual Headless Bangers Costume Ball, Renaissance at World Golf Village. $40–$48, 18+, costume contest, self-pay bar.
• Fri Oct 30 — Boos, Brews and Ocean Views, 1912 Ocean Bar & Rooftop, Ponte Vedra.
• Oct 17, 24, 30 and 31, 8:00–10:00 p.m. — Improv Spooktacular, Third Space Improv. $17 advance / $20 door, all ages, beer and wine, free parking.
• Thu Oct 29 – Sat Oct 31, 7:00–9:30 p.m. — ESTUSCARY Haunted Trail, GTM Research Reserve, 2200 S Ponte Vedra Blvd. Around $20 advance, $30 at the trail, cash at the gate — the reserve hasn’t posted 2026 pricing yet, so confirm. Recommended for ages 10 and up.

Other October evenings worth your time

• Fri Oct 2, 5–9 p.m. — First Friday Art Walk, free, 25+ galleries across King, Aviles, St. George, Uptown, Anastasia and San Sebastian.
• Fri & Sat, Oct 2–31 — Mortality & Mourning: Women in Black, Ximenez-Fatio House, 20 Aviles St. Tours at 6:30 and 7:30 p.m., $25 plus a $1.90 fee. Grief and mourning practices of nineteenth-century women — adult and older-teen material, and one of the most genuinely atmospheric things in town. Also an Overnight Paranormal Investigation on Saturday October 17, 9 p.m. to midnight.
• Sat Oct 10 and Sat Oct 24, 7 p.m. — Salt Run Ghost Paddle, Anastasia State Park. A guided paddle after dark — the only St. Augustine ghost tour that happens on the water.
• Sat Oct 10 & Sun Oct 11 — St. Augustine Greek Festival, Holy Trinity, 2940 CR-214. Saturday 11–8, Sunday 11–5. Free parking at R.J. Murray Middle School with a trolley shuttle; on-site premium $20.
• Sun Oct 11, 3–5 p.m. — St. Augustine Ballet, Dracula, Lewis Auditorium, Flagler College. $30 adults / $15 youth and students.
• Wed Oct 14, 7:30–9:30 p.m. — “A Dark and Stormy Night,” the Tale Tellers’ 13th annual. Not for young kids. Venue and price not confirmed for 2026; last year, $15 at the Limelight.
• The Amphitheatre has a loaded month — Sugarland (1st), Whiskey Myers (2nd), Gov’t Mule & Ziggy Marley (3rd), Boz Scaggs (7th), Tedeschi Trucks (9th & 10th), The Avett Brothers (11th), Alabama (17th), CAKE (21st), Turnpike Troubadours (24th).

Plan Your St. Augustine Halloween

Book in this order. Capacity, not popularity, is what sells out a St. Augustine Halloween weekend:

1. Old Jail After Dark — 12 seats a night, non-refundable. First.
2. Creatures of the Night — online only, no walk-ups, two nights.
3. Dark of the Moon — sixteen nights in October, and the 31st will go first.
4. The lantern walking tour — 25 people, three nights a week. That’s 75 seats for the whole week.
5. Everything else.

Nobody publishes a sellout window, so we won’t invent one. Book when the October calendar opens and prioritize by capacity.

Discounts worth knowing:

• Sykes Family Farms: $14.99 for military or seniors 65+ with ID, against $16.99 general.
• Ripley’s: 30% military across its St. Augustine attractions — not stackable with the county-resident discount.
• Ghosts & Gravestones: up to 15% for booking early, direct only. Direct runs about $30.60 against $36 on the online travel agencies — real money for a family.
• The lantern tour’s private VIP is $100 off for September and October 2026 — $250 for up to 25 people, which beats public tickets at twenty-plus heads and lets you request a guide.
• Jail Break 5K: $35 through October 16, $40 the week after, $45 on race day. Ages 4–18 are $25 if you register by the 23rd.
• Locals Month — free access to two attractions each September for St. Johns residents — is already sold out for 2026. Claim it early next year; it goes fast.

Parking. The historic district is metered and enforced, and downtown fines went from $35 to $100. Use the ParkStAug app — the old ParkNow cards are discontinued. Download it for iPhone or Android before you drive in — the meters are enforced and downtown fines are $100. For the Alligator Farm, ESTUSCARY, Sykes, the Greek Festival and Francis Field, parking is on-site or shuttled and free, which is one more reason those are the easy ones.

Free, and nobody knows: Tolomato and Huguenot cemeteries, third Saturday, 11 a.m.–2 p.m., three blocks apart, docents on site. October’s Tolomato day is the 17th at 10:30.

And there is no official trick-or-treat window. We checked the city and county calendars for 2026: no designated hours, no street closures, nothing. The practical neighborhood norm is roughly 6 to 8 p.m. Treat that as “plan for,” never as official.

Frequently Asked Questions

When is St. Augustine Halloween 2026?

The St. Augustine Halloween season runs the whole month, but it has two peaks. Saturday, October 24 is the family day — that’s when St. George Street, the Ximenez-Fatio House and the Alligator Farm all run their events. Saturday, October 31 is the adult night, with The Alchemist’s Assembly at Francis Field and Prohibition Kitchen’s Vaudeville Extravaganza. Everything else — the corn maze, the pumpkin patches, the ghost tours — runs across both.

When is trick-or-treating in St. Augustine in 2026?

The organized downtown event is Saturday, October 24, 1 to 4 p.m. on St. George Street — a week before Halloween, and in the afternoon, not the evening. On Halloween itself, Sykes Family Farms runs a costume parade and trick-or-treating all day. Neighborhood trick-or-treating on the 31st typically runs about 6 to 8 p.m., but the city publishes no official window.

Is there anything downtown on Halloween night?

Yes, and this has changed. The Alchemist’s Assembly takes over Francis Field 4 to 10 p.m. — vendors, live music, costumes — and Prohibition Kitchen runs its tenth annual Vaudeville Halloween Extravaganza from 9 p.m., 21+. The lighthouse also runs four Dark of the Moon departures, its fullest night of the month. What you won’t find downtown that night is organized trick-or-treating.

Is St. Augustine Halloween good for young kids with a stroller?

Yes, if you aim at the right events. Creatures of the Night at the Alligator Farm, October 23–24, is explicitly not a scare event and is built for ages 2 and up. Ancient City Kids Day, the Ximenez-Fatio festival and the county trunk-or-treats are all free and all ages. The haunted trail at GTM is 10 and up; Old Jail After Dark is 13 and up.

Which ghost tour is best?

It depends more on your guide than on the operator — that’s the honest answer. For the least variance, book something that’s access-and-equipment rather than storytelling: Old Jail After Dark or Dark of the Moon. For the best rating at real volume, GhoSt Augustine. For the cheapest good experience, the $8.99 VoiceMap self-guided audio tour.

Can you go inside the haunted buildings?

Most walking tours are exterior-only — cemeteries through the fence, buildings from the sidewalk. The ones that actually go inside are Ghosts & Gravestones (Old Jail, Potter’s Wax Museum, Cromwell’s Parlour), Old Jail After Dark, Dark of the Moon (the tower and keeper’s house), and the pub crawls. Note that the lantern tour’s “paranormal investigation of the fort” is the Castillo exterior, not inside.

Do we need to book ahead?

For Old Jail After Dark, Creatures of the Night and Dark of the Moon, yes — all three are capacity-limited, and Creatures of the Night has no walk-up tickets at all. Halloween night at the lighthouse will be the first to go.

Were those really hangings outside your house?

Staged ones, nightly, as part of the Ghosts & Gravestones stop at the Old Jail. In my defense, they’re very convincing at 9 p.m. when you’ve been in town four days.

Keep Exploring St. Augustine

• St. Augustine Alligator Farm: An Up-Close Visit in Florida’s Oldest City — the daylight version of the park, including the rookery
• St. Augustine With Kids: Budget-Friendly Things to Do
• Fountain of Youth St. Augustine: Hours, Tickets & Tips
• Nights of Lights 2026–27: Dates, Parking & the Nights a Local Would Avoid
• The Ultimate St. Augustine Travel Guide

If you’re staying through: the lights go on Saturday, November 21, 2026, three weeks after Halloween, and the city changes character overnight. Full guide above.

Have you done one of the St. Augustine ghost tours? We want to know who you got. Drop your guide’s name in the comments — good or bad — because the single most useful thing anybody could build for this town is a list of which guides are worth calling ahead for. It would make everyone’s St. Augustine Halloween better.

And if you’ve ever lived near the Old Jail: you know exactly what I’m talking about.

More from the shopBrowse the full travel collection — St. Augustine, Paris, Iceland, Venice and Tuscany on shirts, ceramic mugs and canvas totes, all original designs.

Keep Reading

Iceland

Iceland Puffins: Where They Go, When They Come Back, and the August Night Tradition That Will Make You Love Them

15 min read

Iceland

What to Pack for Iceland in the Fall: Layers, Waterproof Gear, and What We Wish We’d Known

16 min read

Iceland

10 Days in Iceland: Our South Coast and Golden Circle Road Trip

31 min read